Last Friday I had the opportunity to go the Newark campus of Rutgers University to see Jose Antonio Vargas speak. Prior to showing his movie Documented, the moderator asked us to keep our cell phones on since the purpose of the movie was to encourage conversation on Twitter or Facebook. Quite honestly, I didn’t think anyone was on social media since there were so many of us brought to tears by the film. Although I have seen this film I cried at the point in the narrative when Jose realizes that he does not quality for Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals or DACA (which allows those that were brought here as children to legally work) because of his age. I also cried seeing his mother react to him not acknowledging her as his mother on FB. He did this to ensure that nobody would ask too many questions and delve into his history. I have employed such tactics before and understand where he was coming from. If we are not “out”, we undocumenteds (or formerly undocumenteds) don’t want to talk about the life we had prior to arriving here. Please note that Jose and his mother have not seen each other in approximately 2 decades due to wait times in getting her a visa although she is being sponsored by her mother. Also there is difficulty in obtaining a tourist visa since she is not working in the Philippines (opportunities are far and few over there). She might be viewed as a prime candidate for overstaying her visa without a job to keep her in the Philippines.
During the film Jose was not among us yet. One of his staff was charged with picking him up. Rutgers served some finger foods prior to starting. I had the pleasure of meeting Rev. Ryan M. Eller, Define American’s campaign director over tortilla chips as the room darkened. I told him I was a blogger. Rev. Eller said he would ensure that I could meet Jose later on.
At the close of the film the audience had grown noticeably larger and on the other side of the room I saw a familiar face. Jose received a warm welcome as he made his way to the stage. Among the panel with Jose was Marisol Conde Hernandez (Co-founder of NJ Dream Act Coalition and Rutgers Newark Law Student) and Giancarlo Tello (Campaign Chair for NJ United Tuition Equity for DREAMers campaign and Rutgers FASN student).
They answered questions from the audience that
formed a line behind microphone. I took some hand written notes during the Q
& A. Here are the parts that are clear to me after the fact:
Q. With marriage equality, can you obtain
administrative relief?
A. Jose – admission disbars one from any admin
relief.
Q. The
text under the title of the film “illegal immigrant” is crossed with
“undocumented American” underneath. Why?
A. Language matters, it determines the
conversation we have. (He might have said he was conscious of this as a writer)
Q. Has it benefited your career as a journalist
to be “out”?
A. Yes, the work is richer now than before, it is
more honest.
The long line of students waiting to speak to him
was awe inspiring. I did not have such an experience being an undocumented
undergrad. I was happy that in their respective
situations that they could have each other and also someone like Jose as an
advocate. I was also happy that the immigration debate was at a point where the
language is more widely used and the climate was such that it was okay to utter
the words, “I am undocumented.” Some of them just wanted to tell their stories
and express that his work spoke to their hearts. One petite woman tilted the
mic to her and told Jose that her English was not so good but said that she was
a legal resident. Despite this she has had many experiences where people seemed
to question her rights because she was Hispanic. Jose commented that he found
it pernicious that the words Mexican and illegal were often synonymous.
An African-American woman also told Jose that she
recently visited Great Britain. She said that whenever she told anyone where
she was from she was regarded with a certain kind of awe being an American. She
told Jose that part of her felt like a fraud because she was “looked up to” by
the people outside of the country yet “this” (our immigration issues) was going
on in the United States. Jose had a pained and also humbled look on his face.
He said that he could not imagine what an African-American woman experienced in
our country but was grateful that she could make the connection with him.
Another woman told the panel that time was an issue
for her. She was currently undocumented and waiting for her father to sponsor
her so she could become legal. She was going to be 21 soon. The process could
not happen fast enough as she will no longer be eligible after she turns 21.
The panel member Marisol told her that she must work through her anxiety and
live her life. Marisol is an undocumented law student and said she has to work through
similar issues of one day starting a life with a family. Honestly, this was one
of my issues having been undocumented. The
anxiety of it all is paralyzing. Forget waiting for the fateful day ICE comes
to your door. Working through the anxiety means having to function beyond the
fear to hold down a job, be a student or navigate young adulthood. I believe it took the entire
decade of my 20s to “work through” the anxiety. I might have made better
decisions without it but as it is, there is no getting
back lost time. This woman and I connected briefly since we were sitting in
the same row and were both from Pennsylvania.
The
panel urged us to do the work towards immigration reform in a grass
roots fashion. They said in 1986, the amnesty bill was passed as a result of
Irish immigrants that lobbied hard for change. We were in this together and would only
succeed together. There was also some mention of the “othering” of immigrants
post 9/11 when organizations such as the Immigration Naturalization Service
(INS) became the Department of Homeland Security and the US Immigration Customs
Enforcement (ICE) was created.
There
was strong disappointment towards the President in his delay of an immigration reform announcement until after the November
elections. The disappointment
was echoed by the audience. The panel urged us not to be used as a democratic
pawn because the issue transcended both parties.
Close to 3pm the Q&A session had to be stopped since Jose had
another engagement. I also had to leave since had to pick up my son at
daycare 2 hours away. We were told that Define American was recording videos of
the audience if they wanted to share their stories with Define American. When
Jose walked towards Rev. Eller, I was introduced to him after several members
of the audience got up to shake his hand. In my mind, I wanted to greet him in Tagalog and
express my reverence, excitement and respect. In reality, I responded like
a 12 year old responds to her favorite activist. I must be honest, nothing intelligible came out of my mouth. I believe I said the words “Filipino
history”, “blog” and “stalker”. I don’t even remember telling him my name.
There is a reason why I am not in the field or marketing or the “front man” when
engaging a conference room full of colleagues. I did exchange information with Jose’s team so
perhaps it won’t be the last time we meet.
In the end, it is my shared history with Jose as Filipinos and our
respective work towards the same end that keeps our fates intertwined. Apart
from politics, this issue is about keeping families together. As much as Jose
said “language mattered”, I wish for the day he and his mother are
reunited. Like my son and I do every
day, they’d hug each other and wouldn’t say a thing.
Some interesting information
I learned about Rutgers and NJ while I was there:
·
Governor
Chris Christie approved the Dream Act in Jan 2014.
·
Undocumented
students are qualified for instate tuition under the premise that they attend a
New Jersey high school for at least 3 years and earn a high school diploma or
equivalent. They must also sign an affidavit saying that they will adjust their
immigration status as soon as they are able to do so.
·
Rutgers
University is the second institution to provide financial assistance to
undocumented youth. Financial aid was not part
of the bill that Chris Christie signed.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.